Heretical Gaming is my blog about my gaming life, featuring small skirmishes and big battles from many historical periods (and some in the mythic past or the far future too). The focus is on battle reports using a wide variety of rules, with the occasional rules review, book review and odd musing about the gaming and history. Most of the battles use 6mm-sized figures and vehicles, but occasionally 15mm and 28mm figures appear too.

Tuesday 13 July 2021

Five Leagues from the Borderlands: A Camp Raid AAR.

 Five Leagues From the Borderlands:

For the first time, I have managed to get Five Leagues From the Borderlands out for a full dress game.  I have played a few games with these rules before, but they have been counters on paper just to get some familiarity with the basic rules concepts.

I suppose that 5 Leagues is what some gamers call an "RPG-lite" game, a term I have never particularly liked but it will have to do.  It stresses the combat elements of a 'traditional' RPG but simplifies and abstracts them, whilst making the RPG campaigning and social interaction elements much more simplified and much more abstract.  But more of this later!

Anyway, generating a band of 4 Heroes and Heroines and 4 Followers, and following the capamign turn sequence, I generated an encounter in which the party has tracked a bunch of marauding barbarians to their lair.  I was thinking very much of a Lord of the Rings or Warhammer-type game, so the barbarians here are Orcs who are raiding Eriador and the party is trying to surprise and kill them.

The Set-Up:
The old stone circle (longtime readers may recognize this as the Stonehenge-esque structure I helped one of my daughters make for a school project!)

Occupied by Orcs.  The leader and a few followers are warming themselves by a fire.

Another few Orcs are gathered around a small pool at the edge of the circle, gathering some water.

The party has approached the camp, but the Orc sentry (centre, obscured by the trees) has spotted them creeping to the edge of a nearby glade.  Whoops!

The final Orc sentry is on the far side of the Stone circle (top-left, obscured by trees)

A wider shot of the starting positions of the combatants at the start of the fight.

The Battle:

One of the heroes takes out the nearby Orc sentry.

The archer takes out a second Orc (centre through stones, fallen), but two more Orcs rush forward.

The remainder of the party break left to meet the oncoming rush of Orcs coming from around the pool.

The Orc sorceror (top, slightly obscured) tries to cast his dark magic - so fa, without much effect!

One of the heroines takes out another Orc at the edge of the stone circle.

The sorceror's magic starts to take effect, calling a curse down upon the archer.

One of the heroes has taken out the first Orc approaching from the pool, but the second one is charging one of the followers (centre, with bill)

A few bows are exchanged, and the ferocious Orc downs the follower!

A second Orc fells one of the heroes at the edge of the stone circle!  Four Orcs are down now, but two of the party (one hero and one follower) are out of the battle.

Luckily one of the followers is able to dispatch that last Orc before it can do more damage.

This seems to turn the tide of the battle, as some of the Orcs quickly run off, leaving only the Sorceror and a single warrior Orc left.

One of the heroes fells the warrior Orc after a hard fight.

The archer (bottom) moves forward, dodging the sorceror's spells (top)...

One of the archer's arrows gets the Orc Sorceror through the eye!  The fight is over.

Game Results: I think three of the Orcs escaped and six were killed or otherwise incapacitated.  Neither the fallen hero or follower actually died, but both were injured badly enough as to be out of the campaign for a few days.  A decent haul of loot was found by the party - swag recovered from the Orc raiders.

Game Notes: The rules were very intuitive and quick to pick up, including the quasi-AI for controlling the actions of the enemy fighters.  It is quite a balanced fight, my brief descriptions above don't emphasize that the party was quite lucky to get away with that attack once it had been spotted by the sentry, since the average barbarian (here Orc) is about as tough or a little more than the average starting hero and definitely tougher than the average follower.  The movement, initiative and combat mechanics are all quite familiar, but work fine.  The initiative system involves rolling dice equal to the number of party members, with low rolls (usually 1, but sometimes 2 or 3) being best as they can be assigned to characters to move before the opposition, with everyone else moving afterwards.  So the key thing appears to be to get the key heroes to do key stuff before the opposition gets a chance to react, and then have the others react to the opposition moves.  The combat mechanics don't make local numerical superiority that important compared to combat skill and trying to get advantageous match-ups.  Positioning seems to be mainly important as a mechanism to achieve the latter, by forcing the opposition to attack uphill, across walls or concentrate on the party's strongest heroes etc.  I will resist too much comment though at this point until I get a better mastery of the system.

The campaign procedural game (or the pre- and post-battle phases in more wargamer-y speak) seemed to work pretty well too, both in terms of having workable abstract mechanics to deal with the kind of stuff that a party may want to do (buy stuff, meet people, scout out areas, gamble, heal etc.).  It seems calibrated quite well to be challenging at the start but very importantly to remain so - the rewards for success are definite, but not so great as to really unbalance the game.  

 So overall I am impressed, the game was fun and I am looking forward to playing some more.  What I do need to do is make more 28mm suitable terrain, since I don't have that much really.  If I had only know, I would have collected in 15mm probably, but since I already have quite a few 28mm figures accumulated over the years, it feels like more trouble than its worth to change game size now.  

The game was played on a 3'x2' board, which was fine (normal movement is 4-6") although 3'x3' might be a trifle better.  Figures are a mixture of Bad Squiddo, Gripping Beast, Perry Miniatures, a free Partizan figure (I think!) and Heroquest stuff...


  1. I am surprised to say that this is the first stone circle that I have seen in a wargame - very nice visuals.

    1. Thanks Norm! I was quite pleased how the overall effect turned out.

  2. That's a nice looking game and seemed to play well for (presumably) a solo game. The AI sounds good which can be the undoing for solo skirmish games at a 1:1 level. Looking forward to reading more AAR's and the terrain and figures looked good:)

    1. Thanks Steve, we will see if I can sustain it!

  3. I have played a few games of the SF version (5 Parsecs from Home) - 2nd edition, not the new shiny 3rd Edition that cam out a few months ago. Anyway, like you, I found the battles interesting and the pre- and post-game stuff drove a great narrative. I would play more but got distracted tinkering with my own "RPG-lite" rules. And I also really like the recent 5150 RPG-like title and there is an huge 5150 kickstarter coming soon that will put a whole bunch of encounters and rule into one book. With that, I will then have three games with a similar aim (5 Parsecs, 5150 and my own) but very different mechanisms to play. I am actually looking forward to that over the next few years.

    1. Yes, as you say, options are good (up to a certain point!). Looking forward to getting this back on the table relatively quickly - and I might go for 5 Parsecs at some point too, although I should really give Chrome Hammer an outing first.