Heretical Gaming is my blog about my gaming life, featuring small skirmishes and big battles from many historical periods (and some in the mythic past or the far future too). The focus is on battle reports using a wide variety of rules, with the occasional rules review, book review and odd musing about the gaming and history. Most of the battles use 6mm-sized figures and vehicles, but occasionally 15mm and 28mm figures appear too.

Monday, 1 November 2021

Partizan 2021 & Hobby Update

I went off to The Other Partizan 2021 earlier this month, the first wargames show in meat-space that I have been to since...Hammerhead in March 2020, I think?  Anyway, it was a nice day and the show was pretty busy.  I considered doing a full show report with lots of nice pictures and stuff but somehow the prospect of that felt a bit overwhelming...there was a lot of that about in my mind, a subject which I will return to later.  Anyway, Storm of Steel did a really good video report which I recommend instead!


 And Henry Hyde has plenty of nice photos up:


Anyhow, I did enjoy my day (I had to leave at about 1345 to attend my sister-in-law's birthday party!).  There were a lot of nice participation games, lots of enticing traders and some good looking demonstration games.  It was nice to have a chat, or at least say hi, to a couple of people I know.

From amongst the demo games, the ones that have stuck with me were TooFatLardies' bijou but pretty and very playable looking Infamy, Infamy demo; a good-lucking Crecy game; a mid-C19 Europe game by the Perrys (I think); quite a few WW2 games of one sort or another, featuring a quite wide variety of theatres; a lovely, lovely, lovely El Cid set-up, which made me want to get my own Medievals out and try and approximate some of the nice terrain; a couple of really big mid C18 games; and a demo game featuring the conflict in Syria which I thought was quite edgy - done by the Westbury Wargamers IIRC.  Nice terrain though, and since I can read Arabic I had a fun few minutes reading the posters and advertising hoardings!  I am guessing they were run through Google Translate, since most of them worked but a couple of them were a bit odd...but no matter, the look of the thing was great.  The smallest-scale stuff amongst the demo games was a 10mm Samurai game on Hexon terrain by the Forest Outlaws and Kallistra.  There was a very nice-looking Edgecote set-up by the Northamptonshire Battlefields Society (along with a Northampton set-up which I forgot to take a snap of). I had a good chat with 'Trebian' from the Wargaming for Grown-ups blog too, who had some good ideas (unsurprisingly!) about how to stage treachery in Wars of the Roses battles.

I also played a nice 6mm skirmish game based on the 82nd Airborne at Brecourt on D-Day (as in Band of Brothers), using an adapted version of the All Hell Let Loose rules.





 

The game looked really good, and no less a hobby luminary than TooFatLardies' Richard Clarke came by whilst I was playing to tell the organizer what a nice job he had done! It was a fun game and it worked surprisingly well considering it used individually based 6mm figures, which I normally find a bit fussy and fiddly.  That said, the way the rules worked then it would have been fine if the figures had just been based in groups as in WRG or Flames of War.  Ultimately I think I was sold on the really excellent scenario more than the rules which were...okay, but had a bit too much 'game' in for me.

I wasn't really in the mood for buying much, although I did pick up a pre-order from the Baccus stand and I also bought the second volume of C17/Thirty Years' War scenarios for the Twilight of Divine Right rules.

 It looks to be very much 'more of the same' as the first scenario book: in this case that is a recommendation, as it covers some of the well-known battles of the TYW that weren't covered the first time around (e.g. Lutzen, Rocroi) but in the same manageable proportions.

I mentioned that I wasn't in the mood for buying stuff, which is true but that was more from analysis-paralysis rather than from lack of interest!   There is also an element of my feeling 'stuffed', like I have as many collections and rules as I can deal with at the moment.  Indeed, it often feels like I have surpassed that point.  In that context, my recent venture into 6mm WSS has felt like quite a big mistake.  I love the figures and enjoy painting them, but there was nothing fundamentally that I needed those figures for: everything I can do with them I could proxy with C17 or Napoleonic figures.  So I should really try and limit the size of these armies.

On the other hand, there are plenty of periods and factions I am still interested in exploring: Mahdist Sudanese; NWF Afghans; Byzantines; Greeks & Persians; Carthaginians; Pony Wars; Napoleonic Poles, Westphalians & Saxons; 6mm Moderns, more Air and Naval from WW2 and more recently; SF and Fantasy.  However, storage is an issue - and in fact getting games in at all is an issue, not so much from lack of intent and inclination since I love playing and I feel it is genuinely good for me, but from difficulty in getting time and space for it.  The lack of it has contributed to me feeling at rather a low ebb all round recently, I think.  My hobby has mainly become about organizing toy soldiers and thinking about games rather than much actual painting and playing recently.  The only things I have really got done in the last couple of weeks are some more games of my adaptation of Bob Cordery's air rules from his Developing the Portable Wargame and finished off my 15mm DAK infantry.

It has been my birthday recently and I got a couple of gaming things.  I got the Games Workshop Thorin Oakenshield and Company set which will fill out my fantasy collection nicely, as will the Stargrave Crew box set for my SF stuff.  I got the Gripping Beast Dark Age warriors too, which will be useful for historical and fantasy skirmishes as well.

I am busy this week with two funerals, a work visit and a course but in the margins my aim is to re-establish my painting regime, some research time for scenarios and put in place some measures to get some games on the table.  They will have to be small and portable I think to have any chance of happening, but I do have stuff which fits that bill.  Everything else will have to take a back seat for the moment since the 'real estate' issues around my house aren't going away in the next few months.  So wish me luck!  I am also going to try and get back into club gaming in the next couple of months, which has been quite difficult for me previously.  I am busy until halfway through December but it should be possible after that.  I am local to Nottingham and Mansfield and Newark, so there should be something which suits...



Tuesday, 28 September 2021

Five Leagues Campaign Battle 003 - Heroes & Heroines against Goblin Slavers

My jaunty band of adventurers set forth on another expedition to clear the Bree-lands of the forces of darkness.  A little bit of time has passed since the last fight, since the previous expedition encountered no enemies...

In this encounter, the  adventurers have picked up the rumour and later the signs of a group of slavers.  Tracking them back to their encampment in the dell beneath a couple of old barrows, the group use the cover of the relief and the trees to get quite close...before a watching goblin screams the alarm and everyone starts running at once... 



The Set-Up:

The goblin slavers are based in the dell in the centre, surrounded by barrows and other hills.  The adventurers spotted the sentries by the track previously (right) and so had moved around to attack from the opposite direction (top-left), but they hadn't counted on the other goblin watching from near the river (bottom-left)

The slavers are led by an Orc, who was conferring with one of the goblins just before the adventurers were spotted.

The pair of goblins by the track.  They really weren't expecting any pursuit into this secluded, desolate and (some say) haunted area...

The other watching goblin (foreground) spies the adventurers advancing gingerly through the woods by the river (centre-left)

The Battle:

The archers Nuna and Sommeryth (top) were shooting off their arrows, but managing to miss the mark every time...tricky shooting in the dark dell, perhaps?!?  Meanwhile the rest of the adventurers and the nearest goblins have converged at the edge of the dell...

...which you can actually see better in this shot (top-left); the two goblin sentries (foreground) start running back down the track

A fierce melee has erupted by the edge of the dell; this goblin (foreground) got the upper hand against Ruda, but Gillion (centre) has stepped in; the slaver's chief, the big Orc, has been felled by Leothain (centre-right)

Clahanar felled the goblin escorting the Orc that Leothain defeated (centre); the other goblins have now arrived, as the two archers continue to miss everything!

One of the goblins out-fought Gillion (centre) and was pushing him back up the slope towards the barrow (centre) when finally one of Nuna's arrows hit home, and the goblin fell.

With the majority of the goblins down, the last goblin (the other one was killed at the extreme left of the photo) runs away down the tracks.

Nuna and Sommeryth continue shooting...and continue missing!  The goblin escapes.


Peace returns to the gloomy dell...

Game Notes:

Simple and straightforward fun this one with the Five Leagues Over the Borderlands (first edition) rules.  The absolute numerical superiority of the adventurers, and the local numerical superiority at the initial point of contact, and the firepower superiority, and the generally heavier armour of the adventurers, all added up to a relatively easy fight compared to the two previous fights, which could have gone either way.  
The mechanisms are really intuitive, I feel that I am not actually looking at the rulebook that much during the battles - I spend more time looking at rules details when I am doing the 'campaign' bit than re-fighting these tactical battles. All of which is exactly how you want it for games of this type!  The initiative system is finally balanced to allow the player a bit of agency, usually - but not that much.
 
The solitaire system built in to the rules is basically fine.  It is easy to administer which is the most important thing.  It might benefit from being a bit richer in terms of tactics and so on but since keeping the administration overhead down is pretty key, I am fine with it at the moment.

I did mess up on the figures slightly - I have some goblins who would have done much better as the slavers than the ones from Heroquest I actually used! Oh well, maybe next time...

The Band:

As a reminder to myself as much as anything, the party currently consists of:
 
Gillion (a Dunedan fighter, uses a sword and a mace)
Annungilgweld "Nuna" (a Dunedan fighter, uses a bow and a sword)
Clahanar (a Dunedan fighter, uses a two-handed axe)
Herudoina "Ruda" (a Northwoman, uses sword and shield)
LĂ©othain (a former Northman soldier, now a hero, uses sword and shield, wears full armour)
Davron (a Dunedan squire, learning from Clahanar)
Serronsel (a wily rogue Northwoman, but attached to Ruda)
Sommeryth (a hopeful young Northwoman, archer)
 
Clahanar, Hero, Dual Weapon fighting style, Full armour, 1/4/+1/5, +1 Luck, Quality Sword; Helmet; Skills: Organization, Teaching (the Partizan free 'Martin Schwartz' figure)
Gillion, Hero, Two-handed weapon, Full armour, 1/4/+2/4, Helmet; Skills: Dodge, Parry (Perry 1450-1500 Mercenary captain figure)
Ruda, Heroine, Sword & shield fighting style, Light Armour, 1/6/+1/3, Helmet, Shield; Leadership, Medicine (Shieldmaiden figure - Bad Squiddo possibly)
Nuna, Heroine, Archer fighting style, Partial armour, 2/5/0/3; Skills: Tracking, Pathfinding, Foraging (Shieldmaiden figure - Gripping Beast?)
Leothain, Hero, Sword & Shield fighting style, Full armour, 2/4/+1/3; Skills: Tactics, Library (Perry 1450-1500 Mercenary captain figure)
Davron, Follower, Light Armour, 1/4/03; No skills (Perry 1450-1500 WotR Billman figure)
Serronsel, Follower, Light Armour,  1/4/+1/3, Shield; Skills: Barter (Shieldmaiden figure - Gripping Beast?)
Sommeryth, Follower, Light Armour, 2/4/0/3, Crossbow; Skills: Dodge (Oathsworn Amazon figure?)


Saturday, 25 September 2021

Fighting Retreat at 'El Perez' 1809 - a Polemos Ruse de Guerre battle

As I have mentioned before, each month the Napoleonic Miniatures Wargames Society of Toronto puts on a club game using Glenn Pearce's Polemos Ruse de Guerre rules, which I try to mirror as a solo game in the UK.  The battle for September 2021 is Auerstadt - but this isn't it! What gives?!?


 The original scenario is always designed as a big 'club' game with a lot of figures on a big table.  I don't generally have a problem getting the figures together, but doing justice to the terrain and the wider scenario sometimes requires a bit of work on my part.  Suffice to say, I am still figuring out how best to stage it.   However, I was very much in the mood for a Polemos RdG game, so instead I picked this scenario which was published back in Wargames Illustrated 265.


However, the scenario might be familiar to more gamers as being the Napoleonic scenario featured in the first edition of the Black Powder ruleset.

It is quite an interesting scenario and the write-up in the Black Powder rules is very good.  The premise is a fighting retreat by an Anglo-Portuguese force which has to force its way past a small French garrison to escape, whilst a larger French force closes in.  How easy or difficult it is for a force to retreat varies quite widely between rulesets, so it will always provide an interesting 'test' scenario.

The Scenario:

The Anglo-Portuguese Army:

C-in-C: General Hill
1st Brigade: 2 bases Trained Light Infantry, 1 base Trained Infantry, 1 base Trained 6lb Foot Artillery
2nd Brigade: 4 bases Trained Infantry (inc. 1 Portuguese infantry unit)
3rd Brigade: 4 bases Trained Infantry (inc. 1 Portuguese infantry unit), 1 base Trained 6lb Foot Artillery
Cavalry Brigade: 1 base Well-Trained Cavalry, 2 bases Trained Cavalry, 1 base Trained 6lb Horse Artillery

The French Army:

C-in-C: General Merle
1st Brigade: 4 bases Trained Infantry, 1 base Trained 8lb Foot Artillery
2nd Brigade: 4 bases Trained Infantry, 1 base Trained 8lb Foot Artillery
3rd Brigade: 4 bases Trained Infantry, 1 base Trained 8lb Foot Artillery
Cavalry Brigade: 1 base Well-Trained Cavalry, 2 bases Trained Cavalry, 1 base Trained 4lb Horse Artillery  
Garrison: 1 base Trained Infantry

All the brigade commanders are considered capable and each gets 1 Tempo Point.  
The French garrison unit is immune to Force and Army morale.
The 'Well-trained' cavalry in each army represents a Dragoon regiment, whilst the 'Trained' cavalry represent a Hussar regiment and a Chasseur or Light Dragoon regiment, as appropriate.  If using rules which differentiate cavalry capabilities by 'weight', then make the 'Well-Trained' unit into a 'Trained' medium cavalry unit.

The orders of battle above are those closest to the published scenario.  I think that if doing this again, I would make or consider making the following changes:

Allies:
Make the Portuguese infantry 'Raw' (the Portuguese Army was still being rebuilt in 1809).
Delete one of the foot artillery units.
Consider deleting the horse artillery unit.
Consider making the infantry unit in the 1st Brigade into a light infantry unit.
Consider making one infantry unit in 2nd and 3rd Brigades a light infantry unit.
French:
Make the 1st Brigade into a light infantry regiment with 4 bases of trained light infantry instead; alternatively make a single base in each brigade into a light infantry unit.
Consider deleting one of the foot artillery units. 
The French can have their  foot artillery in a separate brigade with its own brigadier, if so desired.
Consider making the garrison battalion 'Raw'.
 
Terrain Notes: 
The French units do not start on the table.  It requires 2 Tempo Points to bring on a force.
The smaller hill has steep slopes, the larger hill has gentle slopes.
The river is impassable in the time frame of the game, it can only be crossed via the bridge.
 
Objective:
The Allies are trying to get at least 50% of their units across the bridge and off the table. 

The Set-Up:


The French hold the bridge and the town to the West (top-left); whilst the vanguard of the main army is approaching from the East, through the town of El Perez (right); the Allies have a brigade of infantry and their cavalry facing El Perez, with the other brigades in columns heading West.

A closer look at the Allies: the Cavalry (bottom-left) and 1st Brigade (centre-right) are the rear guard of this rear guard, facing El Perez (right); 2nd Brigade (centre) and 3rd Brigade (top) head towards the bridge (top-left).

Another view - note that one of the cavalry regiments has been detached to support the 1st Brigade (top-right)

And another view, this time facing El Perez.

The French garrison, deployed to cover the bridge.  They could have stayed in the village itself, but that would have allowed the Allies to cross the bridge before assaulting. 

And the view between the French garrison (top-left) and the Allied 3rd Brigade (right)

The Battle:

The leading French elements approach: their Cavalry brigade on their left (bottom), the 1st Brigade wending its way through El Perez (top-right) and their 2nd Brigade in the centre (right); the Allied formations, with the exception of the 1st Brigade covering the road, are moving towards the bridge.

Another view

Another view of the advancing French columns

The engagement is well under way now: the French Cavalry have attacked the British Cavalry (left), with indecisive results; whilst the French 2nd Brigade is attacking the right-hand battalion of the British 1st Brigade (centre); the British battalion is shaken by the fire of the advancing French.

Another view

The British battalion holds on, its close-range musketry and bayonets hold the advancing French at bay, who become disordered in their turn (centre).  The Allied 2nd Brigade's brigadier turns back his rear two battalions to protect the flanks of the Allied infantry and cavalry (top-right)

A wider shot of the same

And a closer view of the infantry clash

The effort was too much for the British light infantry battalion however: although the French attack had stopped and descended into a desultory fusillade, the British lights have broken (centre)!

Quickly seizing the initiative to attempt to restore the situation, the Allied 2nd Brigade units launch a bayonet charge!

Meanwhile, the French garrison infantry has been routed by some co-ordinated fire from the advancing Allied infantry.  The plan had been for the garrison to withdraw to the town after forcing the Allied to deploy, but the Allied troops had moved too smartly and fired too accurately.

The mixed results of the Allied bayonet charge: the French Horse Artillery was overrun (centre-left), but the French infantry, despite being in considerable disorder after their own attack, drove off the attacking Portuguese infantry with musket and bayonet.

However, the flanking fire from the remaining British battalion (left) causes horrific casualties in the disordered French ranks, and one of the battalion breaks and runs (right); note that the remaining units of the British First Brigade have withdrawn slightly, so their right now hinges on the farm (top)

The French 1st Brigade has deployed to try and launch a more coordinated attack, but is suffering from British artillery fire (top)

The Allied units by the bridge start pouring across to safety (i.e. the Allied 3rd brigades and half of the 2nd)

A wider view: the French cavalry are reforming for a third attack (bottom-left); the French 3rd Brigade is about to come into action (bottom); the French 2nd Brigade has reformed in the centre; the French 1st Brigade has launched an attack up the road (top); although it has left half its battalions behind (top-right)

The French 1st Brigade's attack is confounded by the fire of the British infantry, and the leading French battalion is routed (centre-right)

The British Light Dragoons have no hesitation in taking advantage of this opportunity, charging the remaining disordered French infantry.

The French infantry flee for the shelter of El Perez.

The attack of the French 3rd Brigade begins to develop however and sees off the British battalion from the Allied 2nd Brigade in short order (top - running away up the hill)

The French cavalry launches another attack, but yet again - without decisive result (bottom-left)

The French 3rd Brigade, being in the most promising position, launches an attack on the exposed Portuguese infantry (centre-left)

Meanwhile, the French Chasseurs lanuch a supporting attack down the vallet (centre-left); however, the French Hussars have finally had sufficient whiffs of grapeshot and have given up the struggle (bottom)

Unfortunately both French attacks miscarry: the French Chasseurs are driven back with loss by the British Hussars in the valley (centre); the Portuguese infantry has heroically stood firm against the advancing French infantry (centre-right)

The British cavalry advances and drives off the remaining French cavalry!

At least the French artillery is causing some casualties amongst the British defenders of the farm

However, the British artillery replies with devastating effect, routing one of the exposed French infantry battalions.

The British Dragoons, supported by the RHA, charges into the disordered flank of the French 3rd Brigade (centre) - the leading French battalions dissolve into rout

At that moment, the entire French brigade breaks and runs!

With the entire French Left in rout, Merle's Division is incapable of further action, allowing the Allies to continue their retreat unmolested.

Game Notes:

A good fun game to get my toys back onto the table after a couple of weeks away. This one was a fairly convincing Allied victory, but wasn't as easy as it perhaps it looked, it was just that the French could never quite pull off that one coordinated attack. As I mentioned at the start, 'fighting retreat' scenarios are interesting as a test of rules since they are a lot easier in some rules than others.  Polemos Ruse de Guerre is easier than some, since it has a relatively generous 'retire' move distance.  The tempo allocation to individual commanders also helps, unless those commanders are plodding, since each retiring force can move every turn, guaranteed.  This contrasts with the Polemos General de Division set, which has no guaranteed movement and in any case, retiring is rather slower.  Both are easier than many rules, which make retiring once the enemy infantry is in musket range very difficult.  

Hopefully this game shows that this kind of game is very easily doable in 6mm on a small table, although the proportions are actually exactly the same as for the Perry twins' original - a 6mm unit base of 6cm is 25% of the unit width of a four-base Perry infantry battalion in 28mm, so this 3'x2' table is roughly equivalent to a 12'x8' table using the 28mm figures, but is much handier is space is tight and much cheaper if money is tight.
 
Figures by Baccus 6mm, buildings by Total Battle Miniatures, Leven & Timecast.