Heretical Gaming is my blog about my gaming life, featuring small skirmishes and big battles from many historical periods (and some in the mythic past or the far future too). The focus is on battle reports using a wide variety of rules, with the occasional rules review, book review and odd musing about the gaming and history. Most of the battles use 6mm-sized figures and vehicles, but occasionally 15mm and 28mm figures appear too.
Showing posts with label Europe in Agony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Europe in Agony. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 September 2023

Not Much Happening Game-Wise...

I haven't been up to much modelling or figure gaming-wise recently due to work/family life pressures. As ever, when things get tight I feel much more inclined to play RPGs, computer games or board games than miniatures wargames; even the painting has suffered somewhat. I have painted some Zulus and British for my youngest and am starting to build some Mahdists and some Agincourt-era knights for him (it has been his birthday this month) but that has been about it, with the exception of some 6mm Dutch WSS infantry (pictures soon); with the result that I have actually managed to build up a little bit of a lead pile: most of my purchases from this year's shows have remained unpainted thus far. Still, hope springs eternal!  And it isn't like I have lost any general interest, just the specific decisions I am making about any spare time have defaulted in the direction of RPGs.

I did get one game of 40K Rogue Trader in with my youngest, which he seemed to enjoy. 


 The good thing about 40K is that the basic system is so intuitive, you can get playing with it very quickly.  In this game, a small force of Space Marines is clearing a slightly larger group of Ork raiders from a ruin and an industrial facility on the outskirts of the jungle.

The hill is scratchbuilt from polystyrene, intended for a new refight of White Mountain (!)



Painting has been painfully slow recently, although I seem to have done a fair bit of constructing and preparing plastic figures. Anyway...

Some Heroics & Ros WW2 French Armour - some reinforcements, so I can field full-strength platoons for all of the major types for 1940

Some of the newer Baccus 6mm US Sherman tank variants

and more, along with some M-10s

Beginning to re-fresh some WW2 German trucks - Opel Blitzes and Protzes? - from two or three different manufacturers

A platoon of A9 Cruisers; this is probably in the 'wrong' paint scheme for 1940 (FoW guidance has this limited to light tanks and infantry tanks, whereas the cruisers were in a more medium green - however, I much prefer this more subtle camouflage scheme).

Some Zulu War era 28mm Perry British Infantry (and very nice figures they are too)


And ditto for their Zulu opponents

Another shot

I am not really sure what to use for playing with these; Neil Thomas has some Colonial-period skirmish rules in his Wargaming: An Introduction I could give a go, although they look at first glance as a fairly crude attempt. Still, worth a try I guess.

Plus some space fighters from Brigade Models - some Neo-Soviet type, I think. They are nice models although I don't have much idea of what to do with them! Perhaps I have an old copy of Delta Vee knocking around somewhere...

and some 'British' opponents from the same range.

Apart from that, it has mainly been RPGs for me (my other blog gives some idea of which games have featured) and boardgames.  For the latter, the two I have been giving most attention to are Europe in Agony, which I find just fascinating, and Over the Reich, as I continue to try and refine my own much simpler WW2 air warfare rules.





Monday, 27 March 2023

Hobby Update 26 Mar 23

I am still making slow but steady progress through the lead hillock although again there has been a lot less actual gaming than I might have liked.  The old conconction of being busy with work (and just as importantly, feeling pretty lethargic when I have finished work), busy with family things and not really having easily accessible gaming spaces and gaming stuff have continued to defy my efforts.  But I have made a little progress in sorting that I hope, so I have a small stable of 'doable' games near my work space whilst everything else gets stored out of the way.

Anyway, first up is more WW2 Polish stuff: an infantry company (more-or-less), a couple of tank, tankette and armoured car platoons, and one anti-tank, artillery and anti-aircraft artillery battery.  These are a mixture of Heroics & Ros (most of the vehicles and guns) and Scotia (all the figures, plus one of the armoured car platoons and one of the tankette platoons).  Annoyingly H&R don't do any Polish gun crews for their Polish guns. Grrr.  In retrospect, I might have been better off using French WW2 gun crews than some spare Scotia Polish heavy weapons crews, they look a bit big. Oh well.



Two platoons of Polish tanks, in their rather nifty camouflage scheme.

The armoured cars and tankettes and tracked artillery tractors.

The Scotia infantry aren't as shapely as the GHQ stuff or as dynamic as Baccus or Adler or as 'correctly silhouetted' as H&R, but they are sort of okay - they are like an old-fashioned Minifig if you like, simple and easy to paint and not quite as reliant on nifty brushwork as some of the Irregular stuff.

H&R anti-tank guns (front), guns (middle) and Bofors AAA (rear)

Next up is a bit more British and German WW2 stuff: the British for early war, the Germans are a mixture.


H&R A13s (left) and A10s (right)

Ok, Panzerjaeger Is at the front, 21 Pz vehicles back-right(a 75mm anti-tank gun on a Somua chassis, a 150mm on a Lorraine and a converted French half-track carrier, I think); A StuG42 and two Hanomags with heavy weapons top-left - these are Scotia, IIRC...

The British have a few Morris armoured cars (centre) and some Beaverettes (right), the latter a common feature of 'what-if' Sealion 1940 scenarios, I am finding.

Next-up is a group of figures that I completed a little while ago, but don't think I have posted: 15mm Cold War Dutch from Battlefront:




The figures were nice enough.  I have done a couple of female head-swaps, using the Peter Pig female head pack.  They are a tiny bit small really but I think that they basically worked okay.  Finding the right colours wasn't as easy as it might have been, but blogger Jemima Fawr did some really brilliant posts on doing a Cold War Dutch Army in 15mm, highly highly recommended!

I have managed to get a figure game to the table but more of that later; otherwise I have been mainly plaing the Thirty Years' War board game Europe in Agony:

Previous experience has told me that you can't get enough 'practice runs' with a boardgame you intend on using as a campaign engine!  Also, actually playing solo and using it as a campaign engine will always require a few small changes to be made, but only familiarity with the game can help you judge the secondary effects of any changes.  But in any case, the game itself is full of interest and I have been learning a lot thinking about the challenges facing Wallenstein, Mansfeld, Tilly, Spinola et al.  Compared to the previous campaign board games I have used, it feels closest to the Gallic War in terms of how the game plays out.  Where this one is a little tricky is that the first couple of turns seem incredibly important in determining the likely flow of the game, since neither side has many troops and they start in pretty close proximity.


Monday, 3 January 2022

The Thirty Years War: Europe in Agony

I have been playing quite a few games of Thirty Years War: Europe in Agony recently, partly for its own sake and partly to evaluate it for use in my planned re-fight of the Thirty Years' War using miniatures. I have also tried to learn the lessons of my last big campaign, the re-fight of the Gallic Wars, which ended with a squib rather than fireworks partly because I played the board-game element of the campaign so badly as one side as to leave it no reasonable chance of victory, despite that faction doing better tactically, in many ways.  This was especially important in that campaign since the factions had to behave in radically different ways and that might not be so much the case in the Thirty Years War, but I want to make sure I do my campaign full justice, so I have been hopefully learning how to play this game rather more competently.
 

The basic elements that one might expect in a Thirty Years War game are all there, it looks reasonably comprehensive.  Most of the political side is handled by card draws, which is fine: such things are quite easily modified for solo play.  In the game, players play one card at a time sequentially, over 6 phases per turn, from hands of 7 cards.  When playing solo, I just use sequential draws from a deck of 6 unseen cards per side, so the strategic choice is only to have the political event OR to use the card for recruiting, army movement, getting foreign aid, and so on.  The mechanics of the game are pretty straightforward really and I got the hang of them after a few short games.  They cover most of the things which one would think should be covered in a game covering the whole of the Thirty Years War!  The actions of the Eighty Years War within the Thirty Years War are somewhat abstracted, and the conflict in the Iberian Peninsula is not covered except as a card-driven even, nor the wars between Sweden and other Baltic nations: the focus is heavily on Germany, Austria, the Spanish Netherlands and Francs.
Combat in the game seems exceptionally bloody and sieges relatively quick and easy.  Combat damage isn't determined by an effectiveness/strength ratio as in most other games, rather a certain level of combat effectiveness simply determines the range of casualties that a force might inflict, which could be a relatively high percentage.  Leaders often have short and exciting lives in this game too. Whilst interesting as a game mechanic, I wonder somewhat about the accuracy of all this (I have had quite a number of mutual destruction battles) but more importantly, how the game will work if the miniatures rules I use prove somewhat less mutually costly. But that is hard to know without actually playing them out.
There are quite a few alternate set-ups published on the internet; some of this is to make it more historically accurate but more pressingly, it is to avoid the opportunity for an easy quick win as the Protestant player in the first couple of turns, since the rulebook set-up allows Mansfeld and the Bohemian rebels to inflict such damage on the Imperials straight-off as to make a subsequent Catholic victory vanishingly unlikely.  With the modifications though, it isn't very clear how aggressive or otherwise each side should be early on.  The force density is quite low in the first turns, which means any serious mistakes in play are very hard to recover from. In some ways, my ECW re-fight faced the same quandary: it logically must be the case that one side benefits more from a waiting game early on, concentrating on resources and recruitment - thus the other side should be attacking.  In a two-faction game, it is hard to reach a sort of Nash equilibrium where both sides best move is to do the same thing.  But if one side doesn't take the optimal strategy early on, then by definition the other side has been given an advantage.  Still, one advantage of solo play is that one can take a bit of time to mull all this over!
Anyway, it looks reasonably suitable and I am quite eager to get started - the only thing I am finishing off is a little re-basing of some of the troops I will need.

Monday, 27 December 2021

Hobby Update: Boardgames - Europe's Agony; Battle Ravens; Achtung Spitfire! & Squad Leader

Although I haven't been doing much blogging recently, I have been doing a reasonable amount of gaming.  For some reason what I have been doing hasn't really lent itself to reviews, AARs or analysis, so I thought I would just summarize my recent activity here, as a marker for myself as much as anything.

Thirty Years War

 The main gaming with miniatures has been more horse-and-musket gaming with Simplicity in Practice: I will deal with that in a separate post.  Boardgame-wise, the main focus has been on playing Thirty Years War: Europe in Agony:


 As far as Thirty Years War games go, this one seems to have been reasonably popular and supported.  A couple of rules questions were answered on the BGG forum quite quickly after I posted them, so some people are definitely still interested.  I am still feeling my way through this game, not so much for the rules as for how the basic strategies of the game work.

Showing the scope of the game - the play area is bounded by Holland - Brandenburg - Franche-Comte - Hungary.  That covers the majority of the Thirty Years War theatres with the remainder being handled by cards.

The area around Bohemia, Austria and Hungary sees a lot of action early on, as the Imperial forces try to defeat a powerful rebellion in Bohemia and a less powerful rebellion in Hungary.

Bavarian forces face some relatively weak opposition around Ulm, but intervening here will cause a negative political reaction in Germany; plus, do these troops need to be sent to Vienna or Prague instead?

Spinola's Spanish are the single most potent military force in existence in Europe at the beginning of the Thirty Years War. Combat in Holland is slightly abstracted by the way and uses a card-driven set of events rather than the usual battle/campaign/siege model in the rest of the game.

My first few games (covering the early years of the war) have been good fun and have shown considerable promise for use as the 'engine' for my proposed Thirty Years War re-fight.  Some very rough, initial observations:

1 - The initial set-up (both in the published game and in the many proposed variants - there is too much chance of easy Protestant dominance in the published set-up, and the variants still seem quite generous to me).  The slight worry here is that the number of forces on the board at the beginning of the campaign are pretty small and the rules quite attritional, so it is very easy to get into some quite odd and one-sided situations very early on.  I don't know how much I should worry about this, but it is noticeable.  Contrast this with the game in the last campaign: Caesar's Gallic War.  That game had some similarities in terms of mechanics, but there was very little Caesar or Ariovistus could do in the first turn to achieve a large degree of dominance.

2 - Sieges seem quite easy to succeed in.

3 - Battles in the game system can be quite mutually bloody: I got three total mutual destruction results in the first three turns!  Nothing about the odds involved makes me think that this would be a real outlier result.  I would be surprised if miniature games replicated those kind of loss levels, so I wonder if that would change the dynamic of the game too much.

4 - The card play is quite important for the strategic framework of the game (new powers intervening, support from foreign powers, generals being recalled, and so on).  There has been some scepticism online about how much some of the cards will get used, although playing solitaire with single sequential draw, it hasn't been too much of an issue in practice for me.

So, some things to think about, but all looking very promising as a game in its own right and as a workable campaign engine for re-fighting the Thirty Years War in 2022.

WW2 Air Wargaming

The air wargames The Portable (Air) Wargame & Achtung Spitfire! have both got to the table recently.  Nothing much to say about either of them: the former is my simple, flawed but IMHO quite enjoyable variant of the air rules from Bob Cordery's Developing the Portable Wargame.  The latter is a comprehensive but for my tastes over-complicated and slow game of WW2 air combat; however, it does seem to produce pretty accurate results and has some great scenarios in.


This is probably the single wargames scenario that I have played the most: two Bf109Es with a slight height advantage take on 3 Hurricanes over France, March 1940.  It is such a great test scenario for WW2 air combat.

The historical result again in this one: one of the 109s is shot down, whilst one of the Hurricane's is damaged (the second 109 escaped easily after this image).

Another great favourite of mine: a simple solo scenario, with PO Richey in the the Hurricane trying to shoot down a lone Dornier 17 at low level in France...

Having damaged it earlier, Richey lines up for one last attack before the Dornier escapes...

And on this occasion, brings it down - just!

The two scenarios above are really good for testing purposes, because they can be played out with Achtung Spitfire! and then compared with simpler sets of rules to see if the simple rules allow things which are simply impossible in AS.  If that happens, it is probably time to change the rules to bring them back to AS outcomes, without introducing AS complexity.  That is basically why I have played them so often!

The third scenario: Blenheim IFs patrolling over France...

About to tangle with Bf110s. Eek!

I think...flying the Blenheim IFs in this one is always going to feel a slightly masochistic exercise...

I often think of this engagement when I hear/read someone riffing on "it isn't the equipment, it is the pilot/crew/soldier" a bit too hard...

Anyway, like a pack of hounds on a wounded fox, the last Blenheim IF goes down...

The same again, but with a larger (double-size) scenario, six Blenheim IFs against eight 110s.

Anyway, all very interesting with AS! and very fun with my much slimmer rules. I must get those rules properly written up and posted (although to be fair, they haven't evolved that much since I last put them up); I am experimenting with some slightly different numbers though, and using d10 rather than d6.

WW2 Tactical Ground Combat:

On a nostalgic whim, I asked for a copy of the classic Squad Leader for Christmas:


I don't think I have much particularly interesting to say about this at this time, except that the basic rules and structure came back really quickly, even though I can't have played for well over 20 years; and that it really was good to get back to Colonel Berki and his boys braving the German machineguns!  Entirely coincidentally, Henry Hyde (from Battlechat podcast, although this particular comment was on a Patrons only Patreon-Q&A session) mentioned that he too had recently bought a copy on a nostalgic whim, although in his case he doubted he would ever get it to the table...I have managed to overcome that particular hurdle, at least.


The initial attack goes in, and despite the usual losses, Berki and some of his riflemen have managed to get across the street...

Lots of fighting across the board now...
 

I didn't take any more pictures of this one, but you get the idea!  I loved it, and have played the Guards' Counter-Attack a couple of times now.
 

Battle Ravens:

Over the Christmas holidays, I also managed to get out Battle Ravens, finally.

This one definitely falls on the 'game' rather than 'simulation' side of the fence: to be honest, one could replace the counters with warriors on for a few different coloured stones and it would work just fine as an abstract boardgame.  The mechanics are really good, give an exciting game and my 11-year old grasped this one without any dramas.  Highly recommended as a game, although it isn't going to replace Comitatus, Dark Age Infantry Slog or even DBM for the wargamer of the period!




Very nice board and counters.  The paper figures are in exactly the same style as the Peter Dennis 'paperboys' which have been doing the rounds for the last few years, and none the worse for that.