Heretical Gaming is my blog about my gaming life, featuring small skirmishes and big battles from many historical periods (and some in the mythic past or the far future too). The focus is on battle reports using a wide variety of rules, with the occasional rules review, book review and odd musing about the gaming and history. Most of the battles use 6mm-sized figures and vehicles, but occasionally 15mm and 28mm figures appear too.

Monday, 24 January 2022

Kampfgruppe von Luck Campaign Scenario 003

The fighting in the Kampfgruppe von Luck pint-sized campaign has now moved on into Le Bas de Ranville itself, as the Panzer Grenadiers of 21st Panzer Division attempt to build on their momentum and roll through 12 Para's defences.


The Forces:

Both 12 Para and KG von Luck field fresh platoons for this battle, as the troops from previous battles are now exhausted, if not dead, wounded or prisoners.

The British forces are based around a fresh platoon from 12 Para. 
British Para Platoon:
HQ: 1 x Rifle Comd group, 1 x PIAT team, 1 x 2" mortar team, 1 x sniper team
1 Section: 2 x Rifle groups, 1 x LMG group
2 Section: 2 x Rifle groups, 1 x LMG group
3 Section: 1 x Rifle group, 2 x LMG groups, 1 x sniper team

The platoon was reinforced with a FOO, with a section of 3" mortars on call.  It was also supplied with Gammon bombs.
German Panzer Grenadier Platoon: 
HQ: 1 x Rifle Comd group, 1 x Panzerschrek team
Squad 1: 1 x Rifle group, 2 x LMG groups
Squad 2: 1 x Rifle group, 2 x LMG groups
Squad 3: 1 x Rifle group, 2 x LMG groups
Possible attachments:
1 x Rifle Comd group (the Company Commander); 1 x Car; 1 x Panzerschrek team; 1 x Unix P107(f) SPW half-track; 1 x Sniper team; 1 x Forward Observer, controlling 81mm mortar battery; 1 x MG42 HMG team; 1 x Werfer strike; 1 x Panzer Grenadier squad; 1 x Pak 40 auf S307(f); 1 x 15cm sFH13 auf Lorraine Schlepper (f)

This is the 3rd Platoon of the combined 8th-7th Kompanie force. 

Once again, the rules are that unpublished set, with strong inspiration from the WRG 1950-1985 Modern Rules 2nd edition, which have been discussed on previous battle reports.

The Set-Up:

To make things a bit easier to follow, I have shown the set-up with all the Paras outside of the buildings (having a quick brew and fag?!?) before the action starts, although most of these elements were inside buildings when the action began.

3 Section is defending the rear line of buildings, with the sniper forward; 2 Section has the forward line of buildings, with some riflemen in reserve in the end 2-storey middle building.

The Platoon commander is in the building on the left, with the 2" mortar team just outside on the other side of the white wall; the PIAT team are outside the building on the right, with the FOO and his team at the apex of the white walls; the Platoon sniper is hidden further along that wall; some of 1 Section can be seen by the hedges and trees (top-right)

Another view

And a wider view; the hedgeline 3/4 of the way up marks the 'edge of the inhabitable world' in the manner of a video game, by the way; more discussion of this in the game notes.  The ploughed fields beyond are purely decorative.

1 Section has its Bren on the flank (top); some of its riflemen behind the hedges (left) and others in a small patch of wood (centre-right); this section is dug-in.

And one more table-wide view, just for luck.

The Battle:

A German section enters the orchard

3 Pl Commander enters at the front too

The Germans cautiously advance forward through the orchards, the Platoon commander one bound behind

All the rank is at the front for this one.  The Kompanie Commander arrives along with another Panzer Grenadier squad

Covered by both the MG42s, some grenadiers get over the wall and into the road

The Grenadiers reach the stone wall...

When the chatter of a Bren opens up enfilading from the flank (centre-left, you can 'just' see a bit of them by the tree) and the Panzer Grenadiers are cut down in an instant

Locating their target, the MG42s open up, their sound tearing up the air...

And after a brief exchange of fire, the Bren team is cut down in its turn

Avoiding the fire, the second squad and the Kompanie commander go left flanking...

Taxi!?! The commander's car and one of the platoon's French APCs turn up.

The shooting having ceased, the Germans resume their advance

A wider shot

The Germans have got as far forward as the road without too many hitches now

A Werfer strike goes in, killing the PIAT team and the platoon sniper; most of the troops in the buildings are suppressed or neutralized for the present

15cm sFH13 auf Lorraine Schlepper (f) arrives to assist - it was a bad time for the PIAT team to go down

The Germans are slowly edging further forward, into the fields beyond the wall (centre-left)

Then, disaster!  The German Platoon Commander becomes a casualty, ambushed by the Paras in the small cluster of trees over the wall

Then the FOO calls in a mortar strike on the German troops in the wood and the orchard - one of the MG42 teams is knocked out, and most of the remainder are suppressed.

Another shot

The Germans have resumed their advance down the road, but the MG42 teams are still locked in a short-range but surprisingly bloodless battle with the Paras in the trees (left)

The black counters placed under the bases of the houses mark which ones were hit in the Werfer bombardment

A Panzerschrek team turns up, accompanying the Panzerschrek team that should have been with the Platoon commander but unaccountably got lost on the way...

The Para riflemen win another firefight and dispose of another MG42 team...

Hit by another mortar strike and having suffered some serious losses, the Panzer Grenadier Platoon's morale is shot and they try and withdraw - but the mortar bombs are still landing around the orchard and the road

The first German attack has petered out

Game Results:

A British victory: the Paras suffered 6 casualties, the Panzer Grenadiers suffered at least 15, with a further 6 missing...

 Game Notes:

A good game, although the Panzer Grenadiers' attack seemed to wilt at a slightly surprising moment - although perhaps it was just me, knowing that without the PIAT that 15cm sFH13 auf Lorraine Schlepper (f) would probably have won the game for the Germans just by blasting the remaining Paras out of the houses.  However, since the Germans couldn't have known that, and the remaining Paras in the buildings were not firing in order to remain difficult to acquire, it did seem justified, I guess.  The Paras' used their mortar support to good effect in this one, although it is much less dangerous and covers much less areas than the Werfer barrage the Germans got, it really pays to be in some kind of hard cover in these rules when under area fire.

The eagle-eyed observer will note that not only am I using a smaller board than usual for this battlefield (2'x2', rather than the 3'x2' I typically use for these refights), but that I reduced the size of the board even more on purpose, by taking away the top 5" or so! What madness is this?!?!

It is because Chain of Command is really designed to replicate an area of only (roughly) 240m x 160m.  Played according to the suggested ground scale, that would mean a table size of 24cm x 16cm - truly micro-gaming!!!.  I elongate the scenarios usually to cover an area of approximately 450m x 300m, more than 3.5 times the area, using a ground scale of 1cm = 5m.  A four-rifle infantry element therefore covers 15m from end man to end man.  A bit close but not inconceivable, although 30m would be better in the open.  Anyway, all of that mostly does not matter, but in the more 'urban' set-ups it really does, hence the use of a reduced size board here.

One 'matter arising' from the game is the subject of withdrawal through fire.  When the Panzer Grenadiers' morale failed at the closing stages of the battle, some of the them had a withdrawal route which would allow them to get away from known enemy positions, but going through a mortar barrage to do it.  What are your thoughts on the realism of this - I would be very interested to know what readers think?  I have always been partial to the Squad Leader rules (summarized) that if you are in cover you can stay put, otherwise you can only withdraw if you aren't in LOS and effective enemy range.   

On the campaign side, the pressure is really on the Germans now - they MUST win the next battle or they will lose the campaign (they won't have enough time left to clear the entirety of the village).


  1. von Luck isn't having much luck is he

    1. No love for my tactical cunning? :-)

      Yes, pretty much. I estimate that the non-player side in this has a base 33% chance of winning. The right cards have got to be in the pack (order probably doesn't matter *too* much in most games) and those activated units have got to activate in useful directions. von Luck's men dibbed out both times in this one, having neither overwhelming force nor crucially a couple of attack vectors - everything ended up butting against a tricky part in the Paras' line. Plus - and this isn't specific to this particular game or rules - if there is an active side, that active side gets a disproportionate benefit as I (the player) get more handy with the rules.

  2. I don't think moving through a mortar stonk would be a particular problem. A stonk from a couple of tubes will only be a dozen bombs, all landing quite quickly. A continuous barrage is something else, but requires far more ammo than the average mortar crew can lug around.

    1. It is a fair point, given the risks of *not* doing so on a WW2 battlefield.

  3. BTW, those are lovely buildings. Timecast?

    1. A mixture of Leven and Timecast I think.

  4. Great report! I do like the ground scale of 1:500 (I was playing my last 6mm at 1:600) with the 6mm. It really gives a feel for the battle. I like the fact that you are only playing with a few bases - a supported platoon or two - and I have been looking at running something similar - not too many units on a small board at 1:500/1:600 just has a really nice feel and look to it.

    1. Thanks Shaun, appreciate that. That look/feel is very much what I am attempting to achieve